Difference Between Congenital Lobar Emphysema Vs Pneumothorax

blog banner
blog banner

Difference between Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE) and Pneumothorax: Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE) and Pneumothorax are two distinct respiratory diseases with different causes and symptoms. An uncommon congenital defect called CLE is characterized by faulty development leading to overinflation of one or more lung lobes, which causes respiratory discomfort. Pneumothorax, on the other hand, is characterized by an accumulation of air in the pleural space and is usually brought on by lung tissue rupture or trauma. This can cause shortness of breath and chest pain. Pneumothorax may require surgical correction or chest tube insertion, depending on its severity and underlying cause, whereas CLE frequently requires surgical intervention to relieve symptoms. For both illnesses, early diagnosis and effective treatment are critical to the best possible outcome.

Difference Between Congenital Lobar Emphysema and Pneumothorax

A rare illness known as congenital Lobar Emphysema is defined by the overinflation of one or more pulmonary lobes at birth as a result of airway blockage, which causes respiratory distress. Conversely, Pneumothorax is characterized by the presence of air in the pleural space and is usually the result of lung trauma or rupture, which causes lung collapse and compromises breathing. The table provides the differences between Congenital Lobar Emphysema and Pneumothorax. 


Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE)



Condition where one or more lobes of the lung are hyperinflated at birth

Presence of air or gas in the pleural cavity, causing lung collapse


Congenital abnormality

Often caused by trauma, underlying lung disease, or spontaneous rupture of a pulmonary lesion


Hyperinflation of lung tissue due to air trapping

Collapse of the lung due to loss of negative pressure in the pleural space


Respiratory distress shortly after birth, often with cyanosis and tachypnea

Sudden onset of chest pain, dyspnea, and decreased breath sounds

Age of Onset

Present at birth or shortly after birth

Can occur at any age, typically in adolescence or adulthood

Radiographic Findings

Hyperinflation of affected lobe(s) on chest X-ray, mediastinal shift towards the contralateral side

Presence of air in the pleural space, with lung collapse and possible mediastinal shift


Surgical resection of affected lobe(s)

Chest tube insertion to evacuate air and re-expand the lung, sometimes requiring surgery for recurrent cases or underlying causes


Generally good with appropriate treatment

Depends on underlying cause and extent of lung collapse; recurrence is possible

Browse The Best Scrubs Collection!

What is Congenital Lobar Emphysema?

Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE) is a rare lung ailment that often manifests at birth or soon after. It is typified by aberrant lung expansion, which causes one or more lung lobes to swell excessively. The blockage or constriction of the airways, usually brought on by a structural anomaly or a mass pressing on the airway, causes this overinflation.Newborns and infants may experience respiratory distress due to this syndrome because hyperinflated lung lobes put pressure on adjacent structures and make breathing difficult.

Causes of Congenital Lobar Emphysema

  • Anatomical Abnormalities: Air can become trapped in the damaged lung lobe due to obstruction or restriction caused by structural faults in the bronchi or bronchioles, the airways leading to the lungs.
  • Intrinsic Lung Abnormalities: Overinflation of one or more lobes may result from developmental problems with the lung tissue itself. This may involve irregularities in the elasticity of lung tissue or deficiencies in the development of the lungs.
  • Compression of the Airway: Obstruction of airflow by masses or lesions in the chest cavity can put external pressure on the airway, causing the affected lobe to swell excessively. 
  • Genetic Factors: Although congenital lobar emphysema is a random condition, in some cases there may be a genetic predisposition.
  • Infections During Pregnancy: The risk of congenital abnormalities, such as those affecting lung development, may be increased by certain illnesses that the woman contracts during her pregnancy.
  • Environmental Factors: Although specific correlations with congenital abnormalities are not well established, exposure to several environmental chemicals or pollutants during pregnancy may raise the incidence of congenital abnormalities. 

Symptoms of Congenital Lobar Emphysema 

  • Respiratory Distress: Swollen noses, retractions (a visible sinking of the skin between the ribs or above the collarbone when breathing), and grunting sounds during breathing are all signs of rapid breathing in newborns or infants, often known as tachypnea or dyspnea.
  • Cyanosis: When blood oxygen levels drop, the skin or lips may take on a bluish color.
  • Wheezing: When breathing, there may be audible, high-pitched whistling noises.
  • Coughing: Coughing is not usually the main symptom, but it can be persistent or recurrent.
  • Chest Enlargement: Because the damaged lung lobe is hyperinflationary, the affected side of the chest may appear larger than the unaffected side.

What is Pneumothorax?

The medical disorder known as Pneumothorax is defined by the presence of gas or air in the pleural space, which is the area between the chest wall and the lung. Breathing becomes difficult as a result of the damaged lung collapsing partially or totally due to this air collection. There are several types of Pneumothorax, including Primary Spontaneous Pneumothorax, Secondary Spontaneous Pneumothorax, and Traumatic Pneumothorax, to name a few.

Causes of Pneumothorax

  • Spontaneous: Pneumothorax can happen on its own without any apparent reason. Pneumothorax that occurs spontaneously can be of two major types:
  • Lung Disease: People with lung disorders including asthma, pneumonia, or lung fibrosis are more likely to experience a Pneumothorax because they have weaker lungs or higher airway pressure.
  • Medical Operations: Chest medical operations, including lung biopsy, thoracentesis (drawing fluid from the chest), mechanical breathing, and central line installation, might result in Pneumothorax as a side effect.
  • Trauma: A blunt or deep blow to the chest can tear a lung's pleura, which lets air escape and collapses the lungs. Accidents, falls, or physical attacks can cause this trauma.
    • Primary Spontaneous Pneumothorax: This happens in people without a history of lung illness, and it is frequently brought on by the rupture of a tiny air-filled sac (bleb) on the lung surface.
    • Secondary Spontaneous Pneumothorax: This form develops in people who have pre-existing lung disorders such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), cystic fibrosis, TB, or cancer. The lung tissue is weakened by these disorders, increasing the likelihood of lung collapse.
  • Rare Causes: Aside from hereditary illnesses like Marfan syndrome or Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, other less common causes of Pneumothorax include high-altitude climbs and scuba diving, which can induce changes in air pressure, and certain connective tissue disorders.

Symptoms of Pneumothorax

  • Sudden Chest Pain: Abrupt, intense chest pain is one of the primary signs of Pneumothorax. When breathing or coughing, the pain—which may be restricted to one side of the chest—may get worse.
  • Breathing difficulties: Another typical symptom is dyspnea or shortness of breath. This happens because there is less oxygen available for the blood to absorb due to the collapsed lung's inability to fully expand.
  • Fast Breathing: As a result of their body's attempt to make up for their diminished lung function, people suffering from Pneumothorax may breathe more quickly (tachypnea).
  • Shallow Breathing: Limited lung function can also result in shallow breathing, which is the inability to take deep breaths. 
  • Cyanosis: When there is a dramatic drop in blood oxygen levels, as occurs in severe Pneumothorax cases, cyanosis may appear. A bluish darkening of the skin, especially around the lips and fingertips, caused by insufficient oxygenation is called cyanosis.
  • Cough: A dry, hacking cough is a common symptom of Pneumothorax.
  • Tachycardia: The body may attempt to adjust for low blood oxygen levels by causing a rapid heartbeat, called tachycardia. 

Shop Best Lab Coats From Here!

Similarities between Congenital Lobar Emphysema vs Pneumothorax

  • Respiratory Symptoms: Breathlessness, fast breathing, and pain or discomfort in the chest are common respiratory symptoms of both Pneumothorax and CLE.
  • Risk of Respiratory Distress: If the function of the affected lung is severely damaged, there is a risk of respiratory distress in both cases. This may result in symptoms including weariness, cyanosis (bluish coloring of the skin), and a fast heartbeat.
  • Possibility of Complications: If a Pneumothorax or CLE is not identified and treated immediately, complications may develop. Infection, deteriorating respiratory discomfort, and, in extreme situations, respiratory collapse are a few of them. 
  • Diagnostic Imaging: To accurately diagnose both illnesses, diagnostic imaging like CT scans or chest X-rays may be necessary. These imaging tests can be used to detect abnormalities in the anatomy of the lungs and to gauge the severity of the illness.

In conclusion, Pneumothorax and Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE) are two separate respiratory diseases with dissimilar etiologies and clinical manifestations. When a baby has CLE, their development defects cause one or more lung lobes to hyperinflate, which frequently necessitates surgical intervention. Pneumothorax, on the other hand, is characterized by the presence of air in the pleural space, which causes the lung to collapse and usually manifests as abrupt chest discomfort and dyspnea. Although respiratory discomfort may be caused by any illness, proper diagnosis and therapy are necessary to manage each one and avoid consequences.

Order the Best Jogger Scrub From Here!

Check out More Articles
Difference Between Tendon and Ligament
Difference Between Seizure and Epilepsy
Difference Between Hypothyroidism and Hyperthyroidism


What is Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE)?

One or more lung lobes are hyperinflated in Congenital Lobar Emphysema, an uncommon illness that is typically brought on by a congenital anomaly in the lung tissue or airways.

What causes Congenital Lobar Emphysema?

Typically, CLE is brought on by anomalies in lung tissue or airway development, which can obstruct the bronchus partially or completely, causing damage to the affected lobe or lobes.

What are the symptoms of Congenital Lobar Emphysema?

Respiratory distress, wheezing, rapid breathing, cyanosis (bluish skin coloring), and occasionally coughing or feeding issues in babies are among the symptoms.

What is Pneumothorax?

A condition known as Pneumothorax occurs when air builds up in the pleural space, leading to the partial or total collapse of one or more lungs. It could happen suddenly or after a trauma.

What causes Pneumothorax?

Pneumothorax may result from medical treatments (e.g., lung biopsy), underlying lung illness, trauma, or it may occur spontaneously with no obvious reason.

What are the symptoms of Pneumothorax?

Abrupt chest discomfort, dyspnea, fast breathing, and, in certain cases, a dry cough are the symptoms. Severe cases might include a fast heartbeat and cyanosis.

What are the differences between Congenital lobar emphysema (CLE) and pneumothorax? Pneumothorax is defined as an accumulation of air in the pleural space that results in lung collapse, whereas Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE) is an overinflation of the lung lobes caused by defects in development.

What are the similarities between Congenital lobar emphysema (CLE) and Pneumothorax? Depending on the severity and underlying cause of the ailment, both conditions may require diagnostic imaging, such as chest X-rays or CT scans, for an appropriate diagnosis. Treatment options may include medical interventions ranging from observation to surgery.